Celtic Castle Designs has Celtic- and fantasy-themed
award templates and other graphics in exchange for a
link back to the site.
Graphics by James -- Award templates available for
"adoption" in exchange for a link back to his site.
Other free graphics, tutorials for Paint Shop Pro, more.
High Power
Graphics -- Award templates, other graphic, other
resources.
Kiwis Graphics
has a few free award templates and other services.
Korea Award offers free award templates by
permission of the webmaster.
Vision Site Design Awards offers free graphics
templates for your exclusive adoption (once you select a
set, they'll won't give them to anyone else).
World Wide
Web Awards has some award templates available for
free to legitimate awards programs.